Selectivity
Most of our students go on to
independent colleges and universities. It is important
to note that competition for admission to the institutions
to which our students most frequently apply has
not diminished. The Ivy League is setting new records
|
 |
More
Links |
 |
|
| |
| |
|
for numbers of applications each year.
On the other hand, some colleges will have opportunities
for students who five years ago might not have been admitted.
We encourage students to look beyond the Northeast in
order to consider the full range of colleges available
to them.
Reputation
Another word of caution -- please make your own decisions
regarding the relative merits of institutions or programs
based on current information. It is easy to be influenced
by stereotypes or past reputations, but times change
and so do institutions! Does this college have the program
you are seeking? Is there a good match between you and
the institution or program? Remember that different
colleges appeal to different individuals for a variety
of reasons, and try to base your opinions on first-hand
knowledge of a particular institution's unique characteristics
coupled with a realistic understanding of the student's
needs and talents. U.S. News & World Report and
other similar ranking systems give only the most superficial
glimpse of a college; they are certainly not ranking
with your individual needs, goals, and talents in mind.
"Early"
Application Options
Early Decision is an undergraduate plan whereby the
student who knows where he or she wants to go and
seems well qualified can apply, usually by November
1 or 15, and receive a decision in December. There
now exist numerous, confusing variations on this theme
including Early Action, Early Notification, Rolling
Admissions, Early Option II, Winter and Interim Options.
Our advice: check out any of the early plans with
the specific institution involved. A student with
a clear first choice and strong qualifications at
the time of application may be rewarded with early
peace of mind. But, changing student preferences and
dramatic academic improvement can make a binding commitment
to attend a particular institution both premature
and uncomfortable. And many students get swept into
the early application frenzy without realistically
assessing their prospects for early admission. (Almost
half of the early candidates are deferred; only a
few of those are later admitted to college.) A student
who wishes to file an early application must feel
that they are as strong a candidate as they are likely
to be based on the junior year record and test scores.
Try not to get caught up in the early frenzy; give
your own situation careful thought.
Tips & Info: How to Choose
Colleges
Choosing where to go for your undergraduate, graduate,
or professional education is one of the most important
decisions you will make. Where you get your degree
can have as much impact on your future options as
the type of degree itself.
Although your choice of where to go to college may
be limited by financial factors, your past academic
record, geographic, or other considerations, it is
most logical to aim for getting the best education
possible within your means. Achieving this goal will
require diligence and forethought. You need to study
the schools and programs, figure out which ones you
can possibly get into and afford, and then apply strategically
to a range of institutions so as to maximize your
options, allowing you to make the optimal final choice.
Here are some suggestions about steps to take to guide
you through this process.
Self-assessment
The first step in deciding where to apply to college
is to assess your self. What are your interests, strengths,
and weaknesses as a candidate? Here are some practical
measures you can take to help you gain perspective:
Think about what you want--and do not want--out of
your academic experience. Ask yourself the following
questions. Some of the answers may be self-evident,
some may take time to develop. It may help to clarify
your thoughts by making lists of what you want and don't
want and refining them over time.
What sort of degree do you want?
An associates or bachelors degree?
Graduate or professional degree?
Masters or Ph.D.?
A combined degree?
What do you want to study?
What subject(s) do you want to major in?
Minor in? Study on the side?
What
do you want to get out of your studies?
Practical career training?
A liberal arts education?
An education in math and science?
Professional
training?
Do
you want to start working right after college?
Do you want to go to graduate or professional school?
Do
you want to work in a highly competitive college setting?
Where
do you want to live?
What
experiences do you want to have outside the classroom?
Create a curriculum vitae, resume, or portfolio of your
work. List your degrees, courses, grades, and dates
of completion. Include information about any research,
publications, conference papers, jobs held, etc. Also
list any references you may have (see "Getting
Good Recommendations" for more information).
Get copies of your transcripts and board exam scores.
See if you can also get an official document confirming
your current class ranking. (Not all institutions provide
this information.)
If you are enrolled in school or college, make an appointment
with your guidance counselor or academic advisor to
discuss your application plans and status. Ask them
to evaluate your competitiveness as a candidate. Also,
ask their opinion about where they think you might consider
applying to school. Seek the same feedback from teachers
or professors who know you well.
Evaluate your financial resources. List all existing
and possible resources, including financial aid (loans,
grants, scholarships, fellowships, tuition waivers,
stipends, work study, etc).
Study the schools
The next step is to gather information about many
different schools and programs. Depending on your
priorities, you might start your search geographically
(looking at all schools in an area you want to live),
by major (looking at schools which offer degree programs
in a subject matter you want to study), by special
programs (looking at schools which offer a special
program of study which interests you), etc. There
are many reference guides available which can help
you to learn about colleges across the world. Consult
comprehensive reference sources which cover a broad
selection of schools.
Once you've acquired a feel for the range of choices,
begin to look more closely at the schools which appeal
to you the most. What information sources should you
investigate?
Visit college web sites.
Visit campuses. Interview with admissions officials
and program or department faculty. Talk to enrolled
students.
Begin early
It's important to start the process of deciding where
to apply early. If you're considering applying to
top-tier, nationally-ranked schools or degree programs,
it is advisable to look into the entry requirements
early. Even if you're not headed to top-ranked schools
or degree programs, you should start thinking about
where to apply at least one year or several months
before applications are due.
Request several applications
Solicit applications and promotional material directly
from several colleges or particular programs. Order
your applications early (typically, the summer or
early fall before the application is due) and all
at once so that you can compare them, digest the questions,
and strategize how you'll respond.
Apply to several schools across
tiers
How many schools should you apply to? Unless you're
focused on just one or two schools where your admission
is assured, it is advisable to select at least three
schools, but more (6-8 or more) if possible. The more
applications, the more offers and choices can potentially
emerge. In addition, unless you're set on applying
to top-tier schools only and are guaranteed admission,
it is advisable to apply to schools that fall in two
or three different tiers--or categories of selectivity--and
to apply to at least two or three schools in each
tier. The three tiers of schools would include:
"Reach" schools that you'd really like to
attend, but which are the most highly competitive schools
you could possibly hope to get into, and which may or
may not admit you. Safer schools are those where your
admission is more assured. Back-up schools that are
not as selective, will almost certainly admit you, and
will still adequately serve your needs and interests.
A word on financing application costs: it is expensive
to apply to several colleges or programs at once.
Budget money early to pay for college applications.
If your resources are limited, look into sources of
assistance to cover the cost. It would be a shame
to limit your college choices because you couldn't
afford to apply to several schools across tiers, as
suggested above.
Results?
If you follow all the steps above and make correct
judgments about your chances for admission at the
schools where you apply, you should receive acceptance
letters from multiple schools or programs.
There is no question that for most students, deciding
where to apply is complicated. Your decision will be
influenced heavily by some factors over which you have
no control -- SUCH AS the grades you have already earned.
It will also be influenced by factors which are entirely
personal. It's normal to change your mind several times
as you try to decide where to apply. The fact is, there
is no precise step-by-step process that will allow you
to choose that one mythical perfect college. For nearly
every student, there are a large number of institutions
where you would be happy and successful.
If the process of choosing that perfect college seems
unsystematic and haphazard--you're right. In the end,
every decision about which college to attend is subjective.
There are many colleges which will offer you a great
education, so you need to keep an open mind as you
begin your search.
If you are JUST STARTING YOUR INTERMEDIATE OR A LEVELS,
you still have plenty of time to do something about
the one thing that will affect your chances of admission
more than any other thing--your transcript. Before you
start looking for specific colleges, you should learn
about what you can do in high school to improve your
chances of admission. If you're a second semester junior
or a senior it's becoming a little late to do much about
your grades. You should begin thinking about colleges
that interest you.
Deciding where to apply:
Directories such as Peterson's Guide to Graduate Programs
are critical to the first stage in your process of
choosing a graduate school. Besides giving an idea
about the breadth and scope of programs available,
they will provide you with complete listings of school
addresses, program directors, faculty members, and
number of applicants/enrolled students. This sort
of information can help you to identify the twenty
or thirty programs in which you have at least some
interest. Throughout this process, however, you will
need to keep an open mind -- schools that you never
would have considered may suddenly sound intriguing,
and programs that you supposed were top of the line
may turn out to be less than advertised. Keeping an
academic diary
with a list of schools under consideration, the date,
and perhaps the reasons for rejecting each program
will be both informative and interesting to you as
the time passes.
Once this initial stage has been completed, you are
ready to request forms, brochures, and application
materials from each school. This is best completed
in July or August, as most programs do not have the
new forms or lists of current faculty printed before
then. Don't bother asking specific questions; most
schools start by sending only the basic information
in their "prescreening" process. Not that
they are evaluating your credentials yet, but they
do try to identify the "I love this place!"
students from those who are "Just shopping, thanks."
Once you have received the standard materials, you
should certainly address these specific questions
to the graduate secretary or program director; that
is, if you haven't already learned the answers through
the initial mailings.
The majority of graduate school guidebooks are ludicrously
inadequate insofar as offering specific criterion
by which to choose a graduate school. The assumption
is, I suppose, that you know what you are looking
for, and that therefore the main factor will be completing
the applications. However, there are many programs
out there that could be right for you, and finding
as many of them as possible will increase your chances
proportionately. An improved selection process therefore
should enable you to choose from significantly more
admissions offers and better financial aid packages.
By considering the many factors involved, you will
forge a process more reasonable and clearheaded from
the start.
Competition:
Who will you be competing against
for admission to this program? Are your scores and
undergraduate grades comparable? Don't get hooked
on a school for the wrong reasons, especially if your
qualifications do not approximate the level of competition
for that particular school. By the same token, realize
that you bring a unique set of academic abilities
and personal traits to any graduate program.
Geographic Location:
For personal or family reasons, applicants sometimes
have only a certain geographic range of schools to which
they can apply. Being as open as possible to different
areas will increase dramatically the prospects available
to you. It also may help you to get in to certain schools
like the University of Idaho, which might want to diversify
its student body. But you will also need to consider
that the school's reputation and alumni network will
be strongest within a few hundred miles of the school,
and therefore many of your post-graduation job prospects
will emanate from this region. If you can't see yourself
living in the area for very long and are applying to
a school without a nationwide reputation, you may be
doing yourself a disservice.
Recommender's Recommendations:
Where did the people who are writing your references
get their degrees? Since admissions teams habitually
evaluate the qualifications of the recommenders (and
what could be better than their own alumni?), these
schools might be well worth considering. Alternatively,
ask your recommenders if they know anyone at the other
programs to which you are applying, or if they recommend
any particular programs for your interests and background.
Remember the saying: "it's not what you know;
it's who you know." Get to know as many people
as possible, and utilize their insight as fully as
possible.
Number Of Students:
This is important both for your own personal tastes
(can you stand being in a program with just a handful
of students… or one with several hundred?),
Urban/Rural Campus:
Where do you want to live? With M.A. programs generally
taking two years to complete, and Ph.D.'s stretching
to about six or seven years, this urban/rural difference
can become a pretty important factor. Of course, it
need not be similar to your undergraduate institution,
and there may be advantages to a new perspective that
you have not yet considered. You may also find that
a novel setting is "acceptable" as long
as you are sufficiently pleased with the other, more
substantial aspects of your environment.
Research Interests: Certain schools have reputations
that emphasize particular facets of their curricula.
If you have areas which you especially enjoy or dislike
to concentrate upon, this can make a big difference.
In fact, the school with the best overall reputation
may not be the one that excels in your particular
area of interest. On the other hand, however, you
may decide to change your specialty after you enter
grad school. How much will this affect your happiness
with this particular school?
Academic Resources:
Library size is something you always hear about in brochures.
You think, "Who cares? How many of these 19.3 trillion
books, 42 million dissertations, and 97,000 journal
subscriptions am I actually going to read anyway?"
Answer: a very small percentage. BUT when you decide
to do a research pape,. you will be pleased to have
one or two special resources on hand. Things like science
labs, computer centers, departmental fellowship funds
and archival holdings in your field of interest similarly
represent the institution's dedication to providing
resources for its graduate population. You will appreciate
them when the time comes; find out what they offer up
front.
Curriculum Choices:
Be certain that the school offers the exact degree you
are interested in pursuing. If you are interested in
more than one possibility, see if the school has both.
It would certainly be easier if you could just change
programs without also having to change addresses, wouldn't
it?
Social Life:
A school's social life will be reflected partly by
the strength of the graduate community, partly by
the scope of public attractions available, and partly
by the atmosphere within the department itself. Articles,
advertisements, and crime reports in the school newspaper
are all time-tested methods of judging the tenor of
social activities
Job Placement:
All schools will say they have a solid record of success,
but how can it be possible to have a tough job market
when all these schools tout "94% professional
placement rates"? Check the figures, ask students,
look at employment listings; in short, do whatever
you can to ascertain the true story on this score.
This will, after all, be the most important thing
to you in a few years (aside from the excitement of
adding a few initials -- M.A., P.A., M.A.T., M.F.A.,
Ph.D., whatever -- to your newly-acquired business
cards). Many schools are accepting students into dangerously
oversubscribed professions. Although the numbers are
difficult if not impossible to obtain, a rough guess
will be an important distinction between programs
for you to consider.
Rate Of Attrition:
Some departments do a better job of weeding out graduate
applicants after they arrive on campus than in admissions.
Again, the numbers are difficult to determine. Check
the size of the entering classes versus those graduating,
query the admissions staff, and ask students currently
enrolled for the real story. If the students have
no idea what you're talking about, fine. If they do,
listen carefully... and ask a few more students.
Graduate/Undergraduate Status:
Graduate students quite often are an afterthought
to the strategic planning of university administrators,
especially since they comprise a relatively small,
self-regulating body of adults who don't tend to cause
problems (e.g., tearing up the newly-seeded football
field, puking on wealthy benefactors, leading demonstrations
against cafeteria food). This is even more likely
if the vast majority of students (i.e., "tuition
income sources") are undergraduates. Check the
ratio of graduate to undergraduate students to see
how outnumbered you will be. This ratio also will
tell you something about the school's social priorities.
If undergraduates seriously dominate the landscape,
the academic and social life probably will also be
skewed in that direction. As long as you don't mind
buying beer for nineteen-year-olds and giggling at
sophomoric jokes, this won't matter to you. Otherwise,
ask.
Accreditation:
After you spend several years working towards this degree,
will professionals in the field universally acclaim
you as one of their own, or will they look at you like
you just bought a Cracker Jack license? Check the number
and status of the various accrediting agencies if you
have any doubts.
Well-Known Faculty:
The opportunity to work under the academic "giants"
in your field of interest is one of the most exciting
thing about graduate study. Be careful about basing
your decision on this, however as this great faculty
member may die, leave, take a sabbatical, or other such
thing. It is true that a faculty advisor who transfers
to a different school often can bring his/her promising
students to the destination program; those who die,
however, leave their students plum out of luck.
For Master's Students:
It may be an advantage for you to consider schools which
offer the Ph.D. as well as the M.A., since they often
can offer richer resources, stronger faculty, and a
broader base of students and alumni. On the flip side,
however, you will want to determine the prevailing attitude
towards masters students in such programs. Finding yourself
on the short end of a preference for doctoral students
can easily make graduate school a much less pleasant
experience than it might otherwise be.
For Doctoral Candidates:
Keep in mind that the major purpose of most doctoral
programs is focused upon publishing, and use that
as an important yardstick for your own choices. What
is the average length of time to complete a dissertation
at the various programs? What subjects have been featured
in previous candidates' dissertations? Is funding
available to students after finishing the comprehensives?
Such questions will illuminate the priorities and
problems that may define your post-Master's work at
this school, or alternatively force you to consider
transferring... and unnecessarily endure this application
process again.
And there are a few more things you may or may not
want to consider…
Age Of Professors?
It may be a drawback to have professors at the twilight
of their careers, possibly unmotivated and not abreast
of current conditions in the profession. Or, it may
be bad to have young professors primarily concerned
with making a name for themselves and moving on to
a bigger name school. You decide if you care or not.
Possibility Of Funding?
Institutions with larger endowments sometimes will
offset high tuitions, but don't count on it. Unless
you are in the hard sciences or independently wealthy,
you're either going to need to scramble for fellowships
or go into hock with a government loan... or probably
both. Greater opportunities for funding may come as
you move down the academic food chain to schools of
lesser reputation, but will it be worth it? It is
best to decide after you are accepted.
Costs or Workload?
Grad school costs a small fortune and requires your
best academic efforts no matter where you go. Any
program that cuts corners to increase enrollment probably
will prove quite disappointing when you receive your
degree. Graduate school bargains, limited workloads,
or "Get Your Degree By Mail!" options should
therefore be discarded. However, there is one exception
to the cost factor: public universities sometimes
can offer subsidized tuition rates significantly better
than private schools without a corresponding drop
in quality. These may be worth investigating.
Special concerns?
Add these to your list. Any means of making your choices
broader and more informed will lead to a more fruitful
application process.
Once you've completed your list, you will need to
locate the appropriate resources for information.
Professors, current students, and professionals in
the field often can provide useful anecdotal information.
Specialized reports can be found in most journal subscriptions
or association reports within your field. Since these
sources reflect the ideas of working professionals,
they hold special weight. In addition, Ph.D. candidates
can find information by reviewing the list of doctorates
awarded by particular departments or by consulting
Dissertation Abstracts, published monthly by University
Microfilms International. Humanities doctoral candidates
may also check the academic journal Lingua Franca
for job placements of recent Ph.D.'s, noting whose
graduates are getting hired and by whom these graduates
are being employed.
More specialized reports can be found in most journal
subscriptions or association reports within your field.
Since these sources reflect the ideas of working professionals,
they hold special weight. In addition, Ph.D. candidates
can find information by reviewing the list of doctorates
awarded by particular departments or by consulting
Dissertation Abstracts, published monthly by University
Microfilms International. Humanities doctoral candidates
may also check the academic journal Lingua Franca
for job placements of recent Ph.D.'s, noting whose
graduates are getting hired and by whom these graduates
are being employed.
Most students apply to far too few programs their
first time around. Don't make such a mistake. When
you finally emerge from the piles of brochures and
personal recommendations and yearly program rankings,
have a solid number of schools to which you can apply.
You will be better off sending applications to a wide
range of programs and deciding between the several
acceptances -- and financial aid packages offered
-- than having few or no options. Applying to a dozen
or more schools is probably overkill, and applying
to just three or four is too few. Seven to ten applications
is probably the most reasonable figure for your targeted
approach.
Choose some very ambitious schools, so that you will
know that you got into the very best school that you
could, and choose some real safety schools as well.
Perhaps these latter schools won't provide the status
or resources that you had wished for, but this is worst-case
planning. Ask yourself, "would I rather go to this
mediocre program or not get the degree at all?"
After doing so, you probably will find one or two lower-dwelling
institutions to fulfill your needs satisfactorily.
|