| Recommendations
are particularly valuable if the person writing
the letter is known to the committee, either personally
or by reputation. A big name in the field, someone
famous for top work, is much more valuable to you
than an obscure teacher. However, don't panic if
you can't get a big-name recommendation-a praiseful,
well-written letter from a lesser light who knows
you well can still be a tremendous asset. A detailed
letter from a less well-known teacher is better
than a perfunctory letter from a big name who doesn't
really know your work. Moreover, the faculty on
admissions committees know that it is often difficult
for students to meet the big
names. One professor said, "Eminent persons
|
 |
More
Links |
 |
|
| |
| |
|
from Harvard or Yale rarely write because
they don't teach undergraduates. At Princeton and Stanford
it does happen."
The ideal letter of recommendation speaks specifically
to your strengths and describes enthusiastically what
sets you above the pack. Valuable letters praise your
quickness of mind, maturity, self-direction, organizational
ability, speaking skills, determination, and research
ability, and use specific examples of your successes rather
than vague generalities.
Some schools give you the option of "open" or
"closed" letters, "open" meaning that
you can see them before they are sent out, it is recommend
that you take the "closed" option. Studies have
shown that letters of recommendation are more flattering
when they are open to the student, and admissions committees
know this. Therefore, committees devalue an open letter.
If you worked hard to deserve a good recommendation from
a teacher, then you don't want a committee doubting the
letter because you have had an opportunity to see it.
If you doubt the quality of the letter you will get from
a teacher, you shouldn't be asking him for it anyway.
Choosing Your Recommender's
Schools:
Most schools require 2-3 recommendation
letters. Choosing the appropriate mix of recommenders
largely depends on the program you are applying for. For
an MBA program, two recommendations from work and one
from school is generally a good balance. If the school
asks for only two recommendations, it would be advisable
to get both work related. As far as possible, it is advisable
to get one recommendation letter from your immediate supervisor.
However, if it is not possible, then a former supervisor
would be a good choice. As a last alternative, you could
use a colleague who has worked closely with you. It is
not advised to apply without a recommendation from your
current job place. For more details, check out the recommendation
letter section on the MBA channel.
Graduate Programs:
For an MS or Doctoral program, you should get at least
two recommendations from your professors. If you have
performed research or worked on thesis, it is highly recommended
that you get the reference letter from your Advisor. If
you worked for a company either full time or as a summer
intern, you could take one letter from your immediate
supervisor.
Undergraduate Programs:
For candidates applying for an undergraduate program,
very few schools ask for a recommendation letter. If asked,
you should get it from one of your favorite teachers in
school.
Some other points to keep in mind while choosing your
recommender:
 |
Choose people who know you well. Rather than
choosing a famous person who has no intimate knowledge
of your skills and abilities, it is much more
powerful to use a person who can illustrate your
strengths and show you at your best. |
 |
Choose people who really like you. It is important
that a recommender invests time in writing your
recommendation. A person who likes you will take
out the time as well as put a positive spin on
your qualities. |
 |
Choose people who are able to express themselves
well in writing. If the recommender isn't fluent
in written English, have them write in Urdu or
whatever language they are used to, and have the
letter translated (an attested translation). Someone
might be a great teacher, and really like you,
but if they are unable to write well in English
the recommendation may come across sounding mediocre
just because of poor language skills. |
 |
Choose people who can address more than one
key criterion: your business and managerial skills,
intellectual ability, leadership potential, maturity,
work ethics etc. |
 |
Give your recommender an outline of the assignments
you have handled at work. Include in the outline
some suggestions on how he/she might address specific
issues such as analytical ability, integrity,
intellectual curiosity etc. |
How to write a letter of recommendation
Initially, the letter of recommendation
should identify its author in terms of academic background
and professional experience. If the author has been
associated with the American educational system, whether
as a student, professor or researcher, this fact should
be mentioned. The person who has had a university experience
in the United States is better able to objectively evaluate
a student's possibilities for success in that academic
system.
Following this, the existing relationship between the
author of the letter and the candidate (professor/student,
researcher/assistant, employer/employee, etc.) and the
duration and nature of the contact should be specified
by the author of the letter. For example:
"This candidate was my student
for two semesters, in a theoretical laboratory course
in the biological sciences, which had as its objective
to introduce genetic and molecular biology to biology
students. This course, one of the department's most rigorous,
awards four credits. During our association, I had the
opportunity to become well acquainted with the candidate,
and this permits me to make a prediction with regard to
his performance in the American academic system".
The letter should evaluate the candidate's level of
ability and performance, from the specific in relation
to other participants in the same group, to the general
in relation to the norms of a specific academic or professional
area. For example:
"The candidate impressed
me as an extremely capable and above average student.
Among the group of thirty students, I would not hesitate
to consider him one of the two best in the class. The
student's academic performance and participation during
the course revealed an ability to think logically, intellectual
curiosity, commitment and critical thinking. In addition
to these characteristics, he consistently demonstrated
a highly developed creative ability while he was my student".
A letter should also mention
the candidate's personal traits - leadership ability,
maturity or others if the author has had the opportunity
to observe these. Finally it is important for the letter
to emphasize the relevance of the foreign program of
study to the professional possibilities in the candidate's
country.
Note:
To maintain the confidential aspect of the letter, it
is preferable that the author of the letter and not
the candidate send it directly to the university. Therefore,
when you ask someone to write a letter of recommendation,
it is strongly recommended that you provide them with
a stamped envelope addressed to the institution to which
it should be sent.
The letter should include:
 |
The recommender's status -- position at the university
or job title. How long has he/ she known the student
and in what capacity (as a teacher, an adviser,
a research supervisor, etc.) |
 |
The better the recommender knows the student,
the more effective his/ her recommendation will
be. They want specifics, NOT generalizations. It
is good to say that someone is hardworking and organized,
but you need to back up these statements with concrete
examples. "Julia is a hardworking student.
Her research project on unemployment in Akademgorodok
was thorough and was an impressive demonstration
of her ability to work with and analyze statistics."
Talk about what the student has done and is capable
of doing. What is it exactly about the student that
makes her or him special? Why do you think this
student would benefit from studying in the U.S.?
|
 |
Evaluate the student by comparing him or her
with other students you have observed in your
work. The following is a suggestions of categories
you may wish to use for comparison. You can use
phrases such as excellent, very good, average,
or below average. |
| |
| Intellectual Ability |
Work Habits |
| Teaching Potential |
Seriousness of Purpose |
| Knowledge of Field |
Emotional Maturity |
| Resourcefulness and Initiative |
Adaptability to New Situations |
| Motivation to Pursue Graduate Study |
Potential for Significant Future Contribution
in Field |
|
 |
Quantify your impressions. Is the student in
the top 5% of his or her classmates, top 10%,
25%, 50%? |
One page is sufficient. Quality,
not quantity, is what is important. Make every sentence
count. Do not put something in if an immediate connection
cannot be made between that information and the student's
ability to participate in the program.
Technically, students are not supposed to see the recommendations,
but the student must ensure that everything is mailed.
Most schools ask that the recommender put the letter in
an envelope, seal it shut, and sign over the seal.
Letters of recommendation vary widely in content and
form, but solid letters contain a number of common traits.
Here below is an outline for a well-structured letter
that covers all main points.
Introduction:
First
Paragraph:
Introduce yourself, begin the
letter by clearly stating your position, where you work,
your relationship to the applicant, and how long you have
known and/or worked with the applicant.
Second Paragraph:
Give your general impression of the applicant.
Body:
Third Paragraph:
Applicant Quality # 1. State
the applicant's most noteworthy quality and support that
claim with a specific anecdote. For instance, you might
say that Samantha is, first and foremost, a born leader;
then, support that statement by telling about the time
Samantha took the initiative to form a task force to deal
with a glitch in the company's computer accounting system.
Fourth Paragraph:
Applicant Quality # 2. Again, state your claim with specific
anecdotes and concrete examples.
Conclusion:
Sixth Paragraph:
State why you think the applicant's plans suit him/ her.
Seventh Paragraph:
State how you think the applicant will contribute to
the program or company.
Last Paragraph:
Strongly reaffirm your confidence in the applicant's
abilities and conclude by telling the readers they should
feel free to contact you in case they need more information.
Don't forget to include your contact information beneath
your signature and name.
Notes about the format
and length:
Don't handwrite the letter;
type it. Handwriting a letter is a sign that you are
not serious about the task and will reflect poorly on
the applicant.
Remember to use official letterhead, to sign the letter
and to include both complete contact information. When
you have folded the letter and put it in an envelope,
sign across the seal.
The length of letters of recommendation
varies greatly, but five paragraphs is usually the
minimum. On the same note, don't go overboard and
churn out seven pages, even if you are highly enthusiastic
about the candidate. Choose your content wisely, and
remember that a concise letter is usually more effective
than an overly verbose one.
|